© 2007 American Public Health Association DOI: 10.2105/AJPH.2005.073940
All authors are with the Department of Agricultural, Food, and Nutritional Science, Faculty of Agriculture, Forestry and Home Economics, University of Alberta, Edmonton. Geoff D.C. Ball is also with the Department of Pediatrics and Child Health, Faculty of Medicine and Dentistry, University of Alberta, and the Pediatric Centre for Weight and Health, Stollery Childrens Hospital, University of Alberta, Edmonton. Correspondence: Requests for reprints should be sent to Noreen D. Willows, PhD, Community Nutrition, Department of Agricultural, Food and Nutritional Science, 4-10 Agriculture Forestry Centre, University of Alberta, Edmonton, AB, Canada T6G 2P5 (e-mail: noreen.willows{at}ualberta.ca).
Objectives. We estimated the prevalence of overweight and obesity in Cree Canadian children aged 5 years (n=1044) using international and US growth references and examined the longitudinal tracking of weight categories between ages 2 and 5 years (n=562). Methods. Weight categories based on body mass index (calculated from measured heights and weights) were derived from the International Obesity Task Force (IOTF) and the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) references. Results. According to the IOTF reference, 52.9% of children were overweight (31.6%) or obese (21.3%) whereas with the CDC reference, 64.9% were overweight (27.5%) or obese (37.4%). The IOTF and CDC references provided dissimilar tracking of weight categories. Based on the IOTF reference, 4.9% of the children who were normal weight at age 2 years were obese at age 5 years. Based on the CDC reference, 14.9% of children categorized as normal weight at age 2 years were obese at age 5 years. Conclusions. The IOTF reference provided more conservative estimates of obesity than the CDC reference, and longitudinal analyses showed dissimilar tracking of weight categories with the 2 references. Public health responses to obesity prevalence estimates should be made with awareness of methodological limitations.
The prevalence of pediatric overweight and obesity in Canada has increased dramatically since the early 1980s, creating a public health concern.1 (Note. The terms overweight and obese are used to denote increased body mass index [BMI]. These terms are used by the International Obesity Task Force [IOTF] to identify increased BMI, but the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention [CDC] uses the terms at-risk of overweight and overweight. We appreciate the different terms used in these references; however, the terms overweight and obese are used in this manuscript for simplicity.) In Canada, childhood growth is not monitored with a national surveillance system, so prevalence estimates have been derived from local,2 regional,3 and national surveys.4 Overweight and obesity prevalence data from Canadian children (aged approximately 6 to 12 years) and adolescents (aged approximately 13 to 17 years) have been well described,4–7 but recent reports have also included preschool boys and girls (aged approximately 2 to 5 years). Data from preschool children collected during the Canadian National Longitudinal Survey of Children and Youth in the mid- to late 1990s indicated that many preschool children were overweight or obese.8 Among children aged 2 to 3 years, approximately 18% were overweight (but not obese) and approximately 27% were obese. Among children aged 4 to 5 years, approximately 17% were overweight (but not obese) and approximately 23% were obese.8 However, because heights and weights were parent-reported, the true prevalence level of obesity may have been underestimated owing to biased reporting.9 Recent studies that used measured height and weight data showed that about 30% of children aged 2 to 6 years (n=1370) in 2 regions of Ontario were either overweight or obese,10 and among children aged 3 to 5 years in Newfoundland and Labrador (n=4161), 16.8% of boys and 18.5% of girls were overweight while 7.8% of boys and 8.2% of girls were obese.3 Results from the Canadian Community Health Survey, which were based on measured heights and weights obtained in 2004, indicated that 13% of children aged 2 to 5 years were overweight and 6% were obese.11 In North America, Aboriginal peoples are the descendants of the original inhabitants of that continent. In Canada, the term "Aboriginal peoples" is inclusive of First Nations, Inuit, and Métis. In the United States, "American Indian" and "Native American" are the terms used to describe First Nations people.12 Community-based surveys have indicated that First Nations children in Canada and American Indian children in the United States may be at particular risk for obesity.13 In the Canadian Community Health Survey, 41% of Aboriginal children aged 2 to 17 years were overweight (21%) or obese (20%), which is a greater prevalence than that seen for other ethnic groups.11 There is evidence from a few small community-based studies that overweight is prevalent in preschool First Nations children. In a published report based on measured heights and weights, 34.6% of First Nations boys (n = 78) and 45.2% of First Nations girls (n = 62) aged 2 to 5 years living in the remote Ontario community of Sandy Lake were overweight or obese.14 In another study that used measured data, high BMI was common among First Nations children aged 4 to 19 years (n = 719) living in the Island Lake Tribal Council in Manitoba. In that study, 85% of girls aged younger than 8 years were overweight (25%) or obese (60%) and 80% of boys were overweight (28%) or obese (52%).15 The issue of excess body weight in young children is very relevant in First Nations communities given their potentially increased risk for type 2 diabetes.15–17 Given the public health concern of overweight and obesity in young children, there has been a call for early surveillance of childhood obesity in Canada and for longitudinal research to understand the pattern of excess weight gain.18 There are, however, several issues concerning the definition and measurement of overweight and obesity that must be considered when surveillance and tracking are undertaken. For example, the term obesity refers to an excessive amount of adipose tissue in relation to lean body mass whereas overweight refers to excess weight in relation to height. Although the term overweight may imply a lesser degree of excess fat than is associated with obesity, no criteria exist to make this distinction.19 From a classification perspective, prevalence estimates of overweight and obesity will vary as a function of the reference population used to group children into relative weight categories.20,21 However, in a position paper developed by the Dietitians of Canada, Canadian Paediatric Society, College of Family Physicians of Canada, and Community Health Nurses Association of Canada,22 it was recommended that the IOTF reference23 be used when making population-based comparisons of BMI-based weight categories whereas the CDC growth charts for the United States24 should be used in clinical and community settings for individual assessments of children. These recommendations were made on the basis of expert opinion, because empirical data were lacking.25
The IOTF reference used age- and gender-specific BMI cutoffs created with data from 6 international surveys of children, and statistical procedures were used to align BMI cutoffs in childhood that corresponded to adult cutoffs for overweight (BMI Few American Indian children were included in the development of the CDC reference, and none were included in the IOTF reference. Despite the inadequate representation of American Indian children, the CDC reference is used to classify them into weight categories.13 It is noteworthy that no Canadian data (neither Aboriginal nor non-Aboriginal) were included in the development of the IOTF and CDC standards. Unfortunately, the current lack of nationally representative measured height and weight data from Canadian children precludes the development of Canadian growth charts, so the use of methods and standards developed by other countries is required to monitor childhood overweight and obesity in Canada. The Indian and Inuit Health Committee of the Canadian Paediatric Society supports the use of CDC growth charts to monitor child growth, while recognizing that First Nations and Inuit children may have growth patterns that differ from the reference population of children who were used to derive the CDC charts.26 Presently, there is limited information regarding the magnitude of overweight and obesity in preschool-aged First Nations children in Canada. There is no information of the comparability of prevalence estimates obtained with the IOTF and CDC references in young children of First Nations descent and it is unknown whether these 2 methods provide comparable longitudinal tracking of relative weight categories in First Nations children. Therefore, our objectives were 2-fold: (1) to determine the prevalence of overweight and obesity in preschool First Nations boys and girls aged 5 years living in northern Quebec with both the IOTF and CDC references, and (2) to examine the longitudinal tracking of weight categories between ages 2 and 5 years with the IOTF and CDC references in First Nations boys and girls who had heights and weights measured at both ages.
Study Sample The James Bay Cree of northern Quebec, who number approximately 14 000 persons, were traditionally a nomadic people. The population underwent a rapid lifestyle transition, most notably in the 1970s, with the construction of massive hydroelectric projects. Although traditional hunting and fishing subsistence activities are still important, the Cree now live predominantly in 9 rural and remote communities along the coast and inland from James Bay between the 49th and 55th parallels in the sub-Arctic region of the province of Quebec. Because of a relatively recent shift to a sedentary lifestyle and away from traditional foods, obesity and type 2 diabetes mellitus have become highly prevalent in Cree adults,27 and the prevalence of overweight among school-aged children is high.28
Data Collection The Cree Board of Health and Social Services of James Bay (Quebec) and the Human Research Ethics Board of the Faculty of Agriculture, Forestry and Home Economics at the University of Alberta approved this investigation. Members of the Research Committee of the Cree Health Board were given the opportunity to read and comment on our findings.
Statistical Analyses
Descriptive statistics for all continuous variables were presented as the mean ±SD. Group comparisons were performed with the independent sample t test. The
Anthropometric data for boys and girls aged 5 years and the proportions of children in each of the relative weight categories are provided in Table 1
Overall, the CDC and IOTF references classified 71.9% of children the same way and the value was 0.58 indicating moderate agreement in classification (Table 2 value was 0.76, indicating good agreement between the 2 references.
For the subgroup with longitudinal data available at both 2 and 5 years of age (Table 3
Unique patterns of change in weight categories from ages 2 to 5 years were noted between the IOTF and CDC references when data from boys and girls were combined (Tables 4
Using anthropometric measurements of Cree preschool children in northern Quebec, Canada, we compared prevalence estimates of overweight and obesity according to 2 different growth references and tracked patterns of BMI-based weight categories during the pre-school period. We found that prevalence estimates for overweight and obesity in children were high, regardless of the reference used to classify children. However, the CDC reference provided higher estimates of obesity compared with the IOTF reference, although differences in the prevalence of overweight were smaller in magnitude. In addition, we found that the categorization of children into different relative weight groups according to the IOTF and CDC criteria differed between boys and girls. The IOTF and CDC references also revealed unique patterns of change in relative weight categories as children progressed from 2 to 5 years of age, which provided evidence for disparate patterns of tracking of relative weight categories with BMI. Consistent with other reports that compared estimates of overweight and obesity in pre-school children with the CDC and IOTF references,20,21 our study revealed that the IOTF reference provided a more conservative estimate of obesity in relation to the CDC reference. In the present study, Cree boys aged 5 years were 1.94-times more likely to be classified as obese by the CDC method than by the IOTF method (40.5% vs 20.9%) while girls were 1.58-times more likely to be classified as obese by the CDC than by the IOTF method (34.2% vs 21.6%). In comparison, Flegal et al.21 found that boys aged 2 to 5 years included in the National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey III (1988–1994) were 1.78-times more likely to be classified as obese using the CDC than using the IOTF reference (6.2% vs 2.5%), whereas girls of that age were 1.95-times more likely to be classified as obese (8.2% vs 4.2%, respectively). In children from Newfoundland and Labrador aged 3 to 5 years, Canning et al.20 found that boys were 2.48-times more likely to be classified as obese by the CDC method than by the IOTF method (19.4% vs 7.8%), whereas girls were 2.01-times more likely to be classified as obese (16.5% vs 8.2%, respectively). On the basis of these observations, caution must be taken when comparing absolute levels of obesity in pre-school children with the different methods. There has been limited study of the tracking of relative weight categories in young children. In our analyses, absolute BMI in both boys and girls decreased between 2 and 5 years of age while the CDC BMI percentiles increased. This finding may appear counterintuitive, but the relationship between BMI and age is curvilinear and tends to decrease from 2 years of age until 5 to 6 years of age (this period has been termed the adiposity rebound 29) before increasing in a near linear fashion until young adulthood is achieved. According to the CDC growth charts, the majority of children who were obese at 2 years of age remained in that same weight category at 5 years of age, whereas the normal weight category was most stable according to the IOTF reference. However, for both the CDC and IOTF references, the overweight category showed the least stability. Cross-sectional data were used to generate both the IOTF and CDC references, so the appropriateness of comparing longitudinal data to criteria generated using independent measurements can be questioned. However, one of the primary objectives of the CDC reference was the development of growth curves to track childhood growth in clinical settings.24 From a public health standpoint, it is clear that different reference criteria can reveal dramatic differences in prevalence estimates of pediatric obesity. If a growth reference does not adequately describe the population in question, public health concerns may be spuriously increased or decreased, leading to inappropriate (or lack of) action.30 Furthermore, when strategies are designed to reduce rates of pediatric overweight and obesity, or if studies are planned to examine changes in growth, the use of different references may correspond to differences in the ability to detect changes over time. As a means of addressing the limitations inherent in the relative BMI categorizations, it would be prudent to express any changes over time in both categorical (normal weight, overweight, or obese) and absolute terms and not rely on a single indicator.31 This information would be useful given that an increase or decrease in absolute BMI could take place but not correspond to a change in weight category if individuals do not cross BMI threshold cutoffs. Our study has several strengths. We determined prevalence estimates from a large sample of young children representative of the Cree communities in northern Quebec, and BMI was calculated from measured rather than reported heights and weights. The study was both a cross-sectional and a longitudinal examination of overweight and obesity in pre-school-aged First Nations boys and girls (to date, an understudied population of children). The limitations of the study relate to the accuracy of the data that were collected. Although a standard protocol for measuring children existed, not all community nurses may have adhered to it. Furthermore, numerous staff used a variety of stadiometers and weight scales to perform measurements. However, we do not anticipate that these limitations resulted in large or systematic errors in data collection. Our data underscore the high prevalence of overweight and obesity in Canadian pre-school children and show that the magnitude of the problem may be substantial among First Nations boys and girls. The high levels of overweight and obesity we found reinforce the case for increased efforts at preventing and decreasing childhood obesity. There is also a clear need to identify the factors that contribute to the onset and persistence of childhood overweight and obesity in Cree and other First Nations children, including the need to understand linkages between changes in growth and changes in food intake and physical activity. We echo recent sentiments made by others9,10 in the need for collecting measured height and weight data among representative samples of Canadians as a means of accurately determining the prevalence of overweight and obesity. The lack of Canadian data are particularly relevant to Aboriginal children, given the large and growing population of Aboriginal peoples in Canada,32 reported high rates of overweight and obesity in Aboriginal children in both Canada and the United States,11,13 and evidence for potentially unique growth patterns in aboriginal children.33–35 Health practitioners working with First Nations and American Indian children should be careful when assessing childhood obesity and be cognizant of the fact that comparisons of BMI with reference standards may lead to inappropriate risk assessments.
We gratefully acknowledge financial support from the Alberta Heritage Foundation for Medical Research for this study. The authors would like to thank the Cree Board of Health and Social Services of James Bay (Quebec) for its support of this study. N. D. Willows and G. D. C. Ball are Alberta Heritage Foundation for Medical Research Population Health Investigators.
Human Participant Protection
Peer Reviewed
Contributions Accepted for publication February 20, 2006.
1. Ball GDC, McCargar LJ. Childhood obesity in Canada: a review of prevalence estimates and risk factors for cardiovascular diseases and type 2 diabetes. Can J Appl Physiol.2003;28:117–140.[Web of Science][Medline] 2. Plotnikoff RC, Bercovitz K, Loucaides CA. Physical activity, smoking, and obesity among Canadian school youth. Comparison between urban and rural schools. Can J Public Health.2004;95:413–418.[Web of Science][Medline] 3. Canning PM, Courage ML, Frizzell LM. Prevalence of overweight and obesity in a provincial population of Canadian preschool children. CMAJ.2004;171:240–242. 4. Willms JD, Tremblay MS, Katzmarzyk PT. Geographic and demographic variation in the prevalence of overweight Canadian children. Obes Res.2003;11: 668–673.[Web of Science][Medline] 5. Janssen I, Katzmarzyk PT, Boyce WF, King MA, Pickett W. Overweight and obesity in Canadian adolescents and their associations with dietary habits and physical activity patterns. J Adolesc Health.2004;35: 360–367.[Web of Science][Medline] 6. Tremblay MS, Willms JD. Secular trends in the body mass index of Canadian children [Erratum appears in CMAJ.2001;164:970]. CMAJ. 2000;163:1429–1433. 7. Tremblay MS, Katzmarzyk PT, Willms JD. Temporal trends in overweight and obesity in Canada, 1981–1996. Int J Obes Relat Metab Disord.2002;26:538–543.[CrossRef][Web of Science][Medline] 8. Statistics Canada. National Longitudinal Survey of Children and Youth: Childhood obesity. The Daily [serial online]. October 18, 2002. Available at: http://www.statcan.ca/Daily/English/021018/d021018b.htm. Accessed October 22, 2006. 9. Tremblay M. The need for directly measured health data in Canada. Can J Public Health.2004;95:165–168.[Web of Science][Medline] 10. He M, Sutton J. Using routine growth monitoring data in tracking overweight prevalence in young children. Can J Public Health.2004;95:419–423.[Web of Science][Medline] 11. Shields M. Measured obesity. Overweight Canadian children and adolescents. Analytical Stud Rep. 2005;1:1–34. Ottawa, Ontario: Statistics Canada. Catalogue No. 82-620-MWE2005001. 12. Word First: An Evolving Terminology Relating to Aboriginal Peoples in Canada. Ottawa, Ontario: Indian and Northern Affairs Canada, Government of Canada; October 2002. Available at: http://dsp-psd.pwgsc.gc.ca/Collection/R2-236-2002E.pdf. Accessed July 1, 2005. 13. Willows ND. Overweight in First Nations children: prevalence, implications, and solutions. J Aboriginal Health.2005;2:76–86. 14. Hanley AJ, Harris SB, Gittelsohn J, Wolever TM, Saksvig B, Zinman B. Overweight among children and adolescents in a Native Canadian community: prevalence and associated factors. Am J Clin Nutr.2000;71: 693–700. 15. Young TK, Dean HJ, Flett B, Wood-Steiman P. Childhood obesity in a population at high risk for type 2 diabetes. J Pediatr.2000;136:365–369.[CrossRef][Web of Science][Medline] 16. Dean H. Type 2 diabetes in youth: a new epidemic. Adv Exp Med Biol.2001;498:1–5.[Web of Science][Medline] 17. Fagot-Campagna A, Pettitt DJ, Engelgau MM, et al. Type 2 diabetes among North American children and adolescents: an epidemiologic review and a public health perspective. J Pediatr.2000;136:664–672.[CrossRef][Web of Science][Medline] 18. Willms JD. Early childhood obesity: a call for early surveillance and preventive measures. CMAJ.2004;171:243–244. 19. Pi-Sunyer FX. Obesity: criteria and classification. Proc Nutr Soc.2000;59:505–509.[Web of Science][Medline] 20. Canning PM, Courage ML, Frizzell LM. Definitions of pediatric obesity. CMAJ.2005;172:310–311. 21. Flegal KM, Ogden CL, Wei R, Kuczmarski RL, Johnson CL. Prevalence of overweight in US children: comparison of US growth charts from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention with other reference values for body mass index. Am J Clin Nutr.2001;73:1086–1093. 22. Dietitians of Canada, Canadian Paediatric Society, College of Family Physicians of Canada, Community Health Nurses Association of Canada. The use of growth charts for assessing and monitoring growth in Canadian infants and children. Can J Diet Pract Res.2004;65:22–32.[Web of Science][Medline] 23. Cole TJ, Bellizzi MC, Flegal KM, Dietz WH. Establishing a standard definition for child overweight and obesity worldwide: international survey. BMJ.2000; 320:1240–1243. 24. Kuczmarski RJ, Ogden CL, Grummer-Strawn LM, et al. CDC growth charts: United States. Adv Data.2000;314:1–27.[Medline] 25. Ball GD, Willows ND. Definitions of pediatric obesity. CMAJ. 2005;172:309–310; author reply 310–311. 26. First Nations and Inuit Health Committee. Growth assessment in Aboriginal children: is there need for change? Paediatr Child Health.2004;9:477–479.[Medline] 27. Thouez JP, Ekoe JM, Foggin PM, et al. Obesity, hypertension, hyperuricemia and diabetes mellitus among the Cree and Inuit of northern Quebec. Arctic Med Res.1990;49:180–188.[Medline] 28. Bernard L, Lavallee C, Gray-Donald K, Delisle H. Overweight in Cree schoolchildren and adolescents associated with diet, low physical activity, and high television viewing. J Am Diet Assoc.1995;95:800–802.[CrossRef][Web of Science][Medline] 29. Rolland-Cachera MF, Deheeger M, Bellisle F, Sempe M, Guilloud-Bataille M, Patois E. Adiposity rebound in children: a simple indicator for predicting obesity. Am J Clin Nutr.1984;39:129–135. 30. Beaton GH. Design of nutrition monitoring and surveillance systems: questions to be answered. J Can Diet Assoc.1990;51:472–474.[Web of Science][Medline] 31. Cole TJ, Faith MS, Pietrobelli A, Heo M. What is the best measure of adiposity change in growing children: BMI, BMI %, BMI z-score or BMI centile? Eur J Clin Nutr.2005;59:419–425.[CrossRef][Web of Science][Medline] 32. Statistics Canada. Aboriginal peoples of Canada: a demographic profile. Available at: http://www12.statcan.ca/english/census01/products/analytic/companion/abor/canada.cfm. Accessed June 27, 2005. 33. Potvin L, Desrosiers S, Trifonopoulos M, et al. Anthropometric characteristics of Mohawk children aged 6 to 11 years: a population perspective. J Am Diet Assoc.1999;99:955–961.[CrossRef][Web of Science][Medline] 34. Lavallee C. Anthropometric measurements and growth charts for Cree children of James Bay, from 0 to 5 years old. Arctic Med Res.1988;47(suppl 1):204–208. 35. Munroe M, Shah CP, Badgley R, Bain HW. Birth weight, length, head circumference and bilirubin level in Indian newborns in the Sioux Lookout Zone, northwestern Ontario. Can Med Assoc J.1984;131:453–456.[Abstract] This article has been cited by other articles:
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||