HEALTH POLICY AND ETHICS:
Roy Cameron, Stephen Manske, K. Stephen Brown, Mari Alice Jolin, Donna Murnaghan, and Chris Lovato
Integrating Public Health Policy, Practice, Evaluation, Surveillance, and Research: The School Health Action Planning and Evaluation System
Am J Public Health 2007; 97: 648-654
[Abstract][Full text][PDF]
I was intrigued and pleased by the integrative approach to school
health issues presented by the authors of this article. Since my
retirement from teaching in 2003, however, I have been serving on the
Environmental Health and Safety Committee of the Massachusetts Teachers
Association. I am concerned about the lack of attention in this project
and in the paper to the sorts of problems we are facing in
Massachusetts. For instance, there does not seem to be integration of
assessments of the physical condition of the educational facilities in the
approach. Indoor air quality is an important issue in Massachusetts. The
long years of neglect of public infrastructure are taking a great toll on the
respiratory health of teachers and children. We have recently discovered
(through the research of Robert Herrick at Harvard School of Public Health) that there may be a
serious problem of PCB (polychlorinated biphenyl) contamination of public schools built between 1950
and 1976. Further, there has not been an evaluation at the national level
of asbestos removal in the schools since the early 1990's. Perhaps such
issues are not important in Canada, but if we are to apply the integrative
approach presented in this paper, we had better ensure that the school
physical environment and not just student behavior is accorded a serious
place in the modeling.